Skip to guide content
My Honest PicksIndependent product guide
All recommendations

wmcnabb084's pick · Updated July 2026

Temptations Cat Treat ShakeUps

Temptations Cat Treat ShakeUps, Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Clucky Carnival, 5.29 oz. Pouch
The pick

I keep a pouch of these by the kitchen because the sound of it is enough to bring a cat into the room. That alone tells me what kind of product this is for: people who want a treat that gets attention fast, without turning snack time into a full production. If you have a picky cat, a cat that ignores dry treats, or one that gets bored when the same thing shows up every day, this is the sort of bag that earns a spot in the cabinet.

What I like most is the mix of crunchy and soft pieces. Cats seem to notice that texture change right away, and it makes the treat feel a little more interesting than the plain hard kind. The flavor smells strong enough to matter, which helps when you are trying to get a cat moving from the couch, out of a hiding spot, or just into the general idea that you have something worth paying attention to. I also like that the pouch is easy to open and easy to shake a little out without dumping half the bag in one go. That matters more than it sounds like it would, especially when a cat starts circling your feet before you are ready.

The small criticism I have is that the pouch could be a little sturdier once it is opened. It closes well enough, but if you are the kind of person who leaves treat bags in a drawer and reaches for them all week, a better reseal would be nice. Not a dealbreaker. Just one of those small convenience things that would make it better.

I've used enough cat treats to know the difference between something a cat sniffs and walks away from and something that gets instant interest. This is in the second group. It is the kind of treat I reach for when I want a little help getting a cat to come over, or when I just want to give a small reward without making a mess. The pieces are small, so I do not feel like I am overdoing it, and the mix of textures keeps it from feeling stale too quickly.

Who this is for is pretty simple. It is for cat owners who want an easy daily treat, not a fussy one. It is for the person who wants something that feels like a small reward and not a meal replacement. It is also for anyone who has learned that cats have their own opinion about everything, including treats, and sometimes the only thing that works is the one that looks and smells like it has a little more going on.

The only reason I am not more enthusiastic about the pouch itself is that it can get a little messy if you are handing treats out fast. A wider opening helps, but a cat that gets excited does not care much about packaging design. I end up pinching the top shut and shaking out just a few pieces at a time, which works fine. Still, a better closure would make it feel a little more finished.

For me, this is the sort of cat treat that stays useful because it is simple and gets the job done. It is not trying to be fancy. It is just a crunchy, soft little treat that cats notice and people can live with. If you want something your cat will actually show up for, this is an easy one to keep around.

Amazon product links on this guide are not currently affiliate links. Neither wmcnabb084 nor Buyer Field Guide earns an affiliate commission from them.

See current price

Keep reading